How to Choose a Real Estate Agent

Before you even think about interviewing real estate agents, the first and most important step is to look inward. Seriously. The single biggest mistake I see buyers make is jumping into the agent search without first getting crystal clear on what they actually want.

Finding the right agent isn't about finding the one with the most listings or the flashiest website. It's about finding a partner who is perfectly in sync with your specific goals, budget, and timeline. Without that clarity, you're just starting a road trip with no destination in mind.

It All Starts With You

Think of it this way: a great agent can't read your mind. The more prepared you are, the more effectively they can help you. That's why I always tell clients to create a simple "Buyer Profile" before we even have our first real conversation.

This isn't some formal, complicated document. It's just a straightforward summary of your home-buying mission. Having this ready makes those initial agent calls incredibly productive and shows them you're a serious, organized buyer.

Nail Down Your Buyer Profile

Grab a piece of paper or open a new note on your phone. Your goal is to create a one-page outline that covers the absolute essentials. This will become your North Star for the entire process.

Make sure you include these four key areas:

• Your Non-Negotiables: What are the absolute, 100% must-haves? This could be a minimum of three bedrooms, a location within a specific school district, or a ground-floor apartment for accessibility.
• Budget & Financing: Be honest about your numbers. What's your absolute maximum budget? Do you have your down payment ready? Even better, are you pre-approved for a loan?
• Ideal Timeline: Do you need to be in a new home in three months, or are you just starting a year-long search? An agent needs to know your urgency.
• Property & Location: What kind of home are you dreaming of? A modern villa, a city-center apartment, a rustic country house? Pinpoint your preferred cities or even specific neighborhoods.

Once you have this profile, you’re no longer just browsing—you're on a focused mission.

What Do All Those Agent Titles Mean, Anyway?

As you start your research, you'll notice that not all real estate professionals have the same title. It’s important to understand the difference, as their credentials often signal different levels of training, experience, and legal responsibility.

According to the National Association of REALTORS®, about 65% of its members are licensed sales agents, while 22% are brokers and 17% are broker associates. The typical REALTOR® brings a median of 10 years of experience to the table, and over a third have a bachelor's degree. You can find more real estate agent statistics on nar.realtor.

This background isn't just trivia; an agent with specialized certifications or deep-rooted local expertise can provide insights that a newer agent simply won't have.

Navigating these titles can be confusing, so here’s a quick breakdown of what they mean for you.

Agent Credentials at a Glance

Credential Type	What It Means	Best For Buyers Who...
Real Estate Agent	A licensed professional who can help clients buy, sell, or rent property. They must work under a licensed broker.	...are starting their search and need a professional to guide them through showings and basic transactions.
REALTOR®	A real estate agent who is a member of the National Association of REALTORS® (NAR). They adhere to a strict code of ethics.	...value a higher standard of professional conduct and ethical commitment in their agent.
Real Estate Broker	A professional with advanced education and licensing. They can work independently or hire other agents to work for them.	...are dealing with a complex transaction and want someone with a deeper level of industry and legal knowledge.
Broker Associate	A licensed broker who chooses to work under another broker rather than opening their own firm.	...want the expertise of a broker-level professional but may be working with a larger, well-resourced brokerage.

Understanding these distinctions helps you zero in on professionals with the right qualifications for your specific situation.

Key Takeaway: The best agent for you isn’t just a good salesperson; they are a strategic partner whose expertise aligns with your specific buyer profile.

By taking the time to define exactly what you need and understanding who you're talking to, you've already set yourself up for a much smoother, more successful property search. Now, you’re ready to start building a shortlist of candidates who can actually deliver.

Building Your Shortlist of Potential Agents

Okay, you've done the homework and have a clear buyer profile. Now it's time to shift from planning to action. The goal isn't just to find an agent, but to find your agent. Forget casting a wide net with a generic online search—that's a recipe for disaster.

We're going to be strategic and targeted. The aim is to create a focused list of three to five highly qualified pros you'll eventually interview. And the best place to start is often closer than you think.

Tap Into Your Network for Trusted Referrals

Never underestimate the power of a good referral. When you’re thousands of miles away, trying to navigate a foreign property market, a trusted recommendation is worth its weight in gold. It gives you a sense of security that online reviews just can't replicate.

Start with the obvious: friends, family, or colleagues who've recently bought property, especially in your target country. But don't stop there. An even better source might be the professionals you already trust—think of your international financial advisor, your lawyer, or an accountant who works with expats. They’re often connected to the best people on the ground.

When you ask for a name, get specific. Don't just say, "Know any good agents?" That's too vague.

Instead, frame your questions to get real insight:

• Be direct about your goals: "We're looking for an agent who specializes in historic villas in Tuscany and has a track record with American buyers. Know anyone who fits that bill?"
• Ask about their experience: "What was it really like working with them? How was their communication, especially with the time difference? Did you feel like they truly understood what you wanted?"
• Inquire about the tough stuff: "Did you run into any snags during the process? How did the agent handle it? We really care about their problem-solving skills."

This line of questioning helps you pull out the detailed stories, not just a name and number. You'll get a feel for their working style and whether they're the right fit for your specific journey.

Analyze an Agent’s Digital Footprint

Once you have a few names, it's time to put on your detective hat. An agent's online presence is their modern-day business card, and it can tell you a ton about their professionalism, market focus, and how they communicate.

First stop: their professional website. Does it look polished and current, or like it was built in 2005 and forgotten? A great website showcases their current listings, features genuine client testimonials, and offers valuable content like market reports or buying guides. It’s a clear sign they’re invested in their business. A well-written blog can also be a goldmine, and you might find useful articles like these real estate investment tips for beginners that prove their expertise.

Next, check out their social media profiles—LinkedIn is a must, but also look at Instagram or whatever is popular locally. Are they actively posting about the market, or is it just crickets? Look at the properties they feature. Do they match the type of home you're after? Pay close attention to how they engage with comments. Their online personality often gives you a sneak peek into their real-world communication habits.

Trust in referrals isn't just a feeling; it's a cornerstone of the industry. In the U.S., a staggering 65% of sellers find their agent through a referral from friends or family, or by rehiring someone they've used before. This just goes to show how critical word-of-mouth and established reputations really are. You can find more insights like this from agent statistics on metropolist.com.

Vet Their Online Reviews and Track Record

Finally, it’s time to dig into third-party review sites. An agent’s own website will always show the five-star raves, but platforms like Google or specialized real estate portals can offer a more balanced perspective.

Look for patterns in the feedback, both good and bad. Are clients consistently praising their responsiveness, negotiation skills, or deep local knowledge? On the flip side, how did they handle it when things went wrong? A single negative review isn't a deal-breaker—sometimes things just don't work out. But multiple complaints about poor communication or dropping the ball on details? That’s a massive red flag.

By combining personal recommendations with this kind of thorough online vetting, you’ll build a high-quality shortlist. This methodical approach ensures you're lining up interviews with top-tier candidates who are genuinely equipped to help you succeed. Now, you’re ready for the most important part: the interview.

The Interview Questions That Reveal a Great Agent

Okay, you’ve done your homework and have a shortlist of potential agents. Now for the most important part of the entire selection process: the interview. This is so much more than a formality. It's your chance to see past the polished online profile and figure out who you’ll actually be working with on this massive financial—and often emotional—journey.

Your goal here is to get beyond the sales pitch. You need to really dig into their expertise, see how they communicate, and most importantly, get a feel for their character. Are they truly in your corner, or are they just trying to close a deal as fast as possible? The right questions will tell you everything.

This decision tree gives you a great visual of how to get from that initial idea to a solid, vetted shortlist.

As you can see, it doesn't matter if you start with a referral from a friend or a Google search. The non-negotiable step is always that deep-dive vetting before you start making calls.

Gauging Their Local Expertise

Anyone can pull up listings online. A truly great agent brings something to the table you just can't get from a website: genuine, on-the-ground local insight. For an international buyer who can't just pop over for a weekend drive-by, this kind of knowledge is pure gold.

You need to probe their local expertise directly.

• "Can you describe what's happening in my target neighborhood right now? Are homes selling for over or under the list price?" A vague answer is a huge red flag. A top agent should fire back with specifics—recent sale prices, how many homes are for sale, and whether it’s a buyer's or seller's market in that exact area.
• "What are the common quirks or challenges of buying in this specific town?" Every place has its own personality and its own problems. Maybe it’s strict historical district rules, known flooding issues, or complex local taxes. An experienced agent will know these pitfalls and, crucially, how to handle them.
• "Based on what I've told you, are there any other neighborhoods you think I should consider?" This is a fantastic test of their listening skills and creativity. A great agent won’t just be an order-taker; they'll use their expertise to suggest a hidden gem or an alternative spot that checks all your boxes.

Understanding Their Process and Communication

How an agent works is just as critical as what they know. You need their process to mesh with your own, especially when you're coordinating across different time zones. A mismatch in communication styles can quickly turn this exciting process into a frustrating mess of missed calls and confusing emails.

Pro Tip: Pay very close attention to whether the agent asks you questions. A real pro will be just as focused on understanding your needs as they are on selling themselves. It should feel like a two-way conversation, not a one-sided sales pitch.

Here’s how to get a feel for their operational style:

• "What's your preferred way to communicate, and how often will I hear from you?" There's no single "right" answer here, but it has to be right for you. If you need quick daily texts and they only send a weekly email summary, it's not going to work.
• "How many other clients are you actively working with at the moment?" You don't want an agent with zero clients, but someone juggling 20 active buyers might not have the bandwidth for the hands-on support an international purchase requires. Look for honesty and a number that feels balanced.
• "Walk me through your process once we find a property we love. What are the immediate next steps?" They should be able to lay out the entire offer-to-closing roadmap with total confidence. This proves they're organized and experienced. If they hesitate or seem unsure, it’s a major warning sign.

Probing Their Negotiation Philosophy and Problem-Solving Skills

Buying a home is rarely a straight shot. Things go sideways. A bad inspection report, a last-minute financing snag, a difficult seller—these are all part of the game. You need a calm, strategic problem-solver in your corner, not just someone who can open a lockbox.

These questions will reveal how they perform under pressure.

• "Tell me about a time a deal got really complicated. What was the issue, and how did you fix it for your client?" This pushes them beyond hypotheticals and into real-world examples of their skills.
• "What's your approach to negotiation? Are you more aggressive or collaborative?" This gets to the heart of their style. You want someone who will champion your interests but who also knows how to keep a deal from falling apart by working with the other side.
• "How do you help clients figure out a fair offer price?" A great agent will immediately start talking about a comparative market analysis (CMA), looking at recent sales data, and factoring in the property's specific condition. They won't just pull a number out of thin air.

For those looking at this as an investment property, you should also ask about their professional network. For instance, if you plan to rent it out, you can get a head start by learning from them about how to choose a property management company. The quality of their connections often says a lot about their own experience.

To help you organize your thoughts during these crucial calls, here's a table you can use.

Key Interview Questions and What to Look For

Use this table as your guide during the interviews. It’ll help you ask consistent questions and objectively compare how each agent measures up.

Question Category	Sample Question	Green Flag Answer	Red Flag Answer
Local Expertise	"What are the pros and cons of the specific neighborhoods I'm interested in?"	Provides detailed, nuanced insights about schools, amenities, commute times, and future development plans. Mentions things you can't find online.	Gives generic, brochure-like descriptions. Doesn't know the specifics of one area versus another just a few blocks away.
Experience	"What percentage of your clients are international buyers like me?"	Has a clear track record with international clients. Understands the unique challenges of time zones, remote viewings, and international fund transfers.	Admits they have little to no experience with international buyers. Seems unsure about the specific legal or logistical hurdles involved.
Communication	"How will you keep me in the loop, especially with the time difference?"	Proposes a clear plan (e.g., daily email summaries, weekly video calls). Is flexible and asks about your preferred communication tools (WhatsApp, Zoom, etc.).	Is vague about a plan. Says "I'll just call you" without considering the time difference. Seems rigid in their communication style.
Problem-Solving	"Tell me about a past deal that almost fell through. How did you save it?"	Shares a specific story where they identified a problem early, communicated clearly with their client, and found a creative solution to keep the deal on track.	Blames the other agent, the seller, or the lender. Doesn't take ownership or can't provide a concrete example of their problem-solving skills.
Negotiation	"How will you ensure I don't overpay in this market?"	Explains their process for creating a detailed CMA. Discusses how they'll use comparable sales, property condition, and market trends to justify an offer price.	Focuses only on "winning" or "being aggressive." Suggests offering the asking price without a data-backed strategy.

After a few of these conversations, you’ll have a much clearer picture. The right agent won't just give you good answers—they'll make you feel confident and understood. Trust that gut feeling.

Why You Need a Specialist, Not a Generalist

When you’re buying property from overseas, it's easy to assume any seasoned agent can handle the deal. But here’s a hard-earned truth: the difference between a generalist and a true specialist can make or break your entire experience. An agent who claims to do everything often isn't a master of anything, and in a high-stakes real estate transaction, that’s a risk you can’t afford.

Think about it. You wouldn't ask your family doctor to perform brain surgery. You'd seek out a top neurosurgeon—someone who lives and breathes that specific discipline. Real estate is no different. An agent who’s the king of luxury downtown condos might be completely out of their element trying to navigate the complexities of a suburban family home in a top-rated school district.

Pinpointing an Expert for Your Exact Goal

The global real estate market is enormous—we're talking a $488.8 billion industry. With that kind of scale, agents have become hyper-specialized to stand out. For instance, with nearly 79% of U.S. buyers going for detached single-family homes, many agents build their entire careers catering to just that segment. This specialization is a huge advantage for you, because it means there’s an agent out there who is a perfect match for what you’re looking for. You can dive deeper into real estate market trends on cognitivemarketresearch.com.

This focus isn't just about the type of house; it's about you as a buyer. You'll find agents who build their reputation around specific client needs:

• First-Time Homebuyers: These agents are part coach, part guide. They excel at breaking down the process and holding your hand from start to finish.
• Investment Properties: An investment pro talks numbers—cap rates, cash flow, and local rental laws. Their approach is all about ROI.
• Luxury Homes: This world requires ultimate discretion, a powerful network, and a deep understanding of what high-net-worth buyers expect.
• Architectural Styles: Dreaming of a mid-century modern or a historic brownstone? Some agents are treasure hunters for specific architectural gems.

When you hire an agent with this kind of deep, narrow focus, you’re not just hiring help—you’re hiring a strategic partner who has already seen and solved the problems you’re about to face.

How to Tell a Real Pro from a Pretender

Anyone can slap "Luxury Specialist" on a business card. Your job is to verify that claim. During your interviews, you need to dig in and ask for proof. A true expert won't be offended; they'll be eager to show you their credentials.

First, ask to see a list of their sales from the last 12 months. Does their track record actually match their supposed niche? If they say they're the go-to agent for waterfront properties, you should see a list dominated by lakefront or coastal homes, not a random mix of condos and starter houses miles inland.

My Two Cents: An agent's claimed specialty should be glaringly obvious from their recent sales history. If you have to squint to see the pattern, it’s not really a specialty. Always ask for the data.

Next, ask them for a story. A great prompt is, "Tell me about a recent deal you handled for an international buyer like me. What went wrong, and how did you fix it?" Their answer will tell you everything you need to know about their real-world problem-solving skills and whether they’ve truly walked this path before.

Finally, ask for references from past clients who were in your shoes. There is no better validation than speaking with someone who has already been through the process with this agent. If they can confidently connect you with happy clients, it’s a strong sign you’ve found the real deal.

Making the Final Call and Sealing the Partnership

You’ve done your homework. You've dug into their online presence, grilled them in interviews, and now you’re down to the wire. This is the moment you shift from evaluating candidates to choosing your partner.

It’s about more than just a final check and a signature. It’s also about trusting your gut. The goal is to sign that agreement feeling completely confident that you have a dedicated advocate ready to go to bat for you.

Conduct In-Depth Reference Checks

A great agent will be proud to share references from past clients, especially from people in your shoes—other international buyers. Don't just go through the motions here. This is your chance to get a candid, unfiltered look at what it’s really like to work with them day-to-day.

When you get someone on the phone, move past the generic questions. You need to ask targeted questions that get to the heart of their performance.

Questions to Ask an Agent's Past Clients:

• Communication Style: "How did the agent manage the time zone difference? Were they proactive with updates, or did you find yourself chasing them down for information?"
• Problem-Solving Skills: "Could you tell me about an unexpected hiccup during the process? I'm curious to know exactly how the agent handled it."
• Negotiation Prowess: "When it came to negotiations, did you feel like they were truly fighting for your best interests? How did they guide you to the final price?"
• Overall Experience: "Looking back, is there one thing you wish the agent had done differently? On the flip side, what was the most valuable thing they did for you?"

The answers you get are gold. They provide a real-world view that complements the promises made in an interview. If you hear consistent praise for their communication and creative problem-solving, that’s a very good sign.

Understanding the Buyer Representation Agreement

Once you’ve made your decision, it’s time to make it official with a buyer representation agreement. This is a formal contract that lays out the rules of engagement for your partnership. It’s there to protect both of you by making sure everyone’s expectations are clear from the start.

Never, ever sign this document without reading every word. The specifics can change depending on your location, but a few key clauses need your full attention.

Key Takeaway: The buyer representation agreement is more than just paperwork—it’s the foundation of your professional relationship. It clarifies duties and prevents major headaches later on.

Before your pen hits the paper, get crystal clear on these four points:

• Commission Structure: Who pays the agent, and how? In many places, the seller covers the commission, but that's not a universal rule. Get this confirmed in writing.
• Contract Length (Term): How long are you locked in for? A typical agreement runs for three to six months. Be wary of anyone pushing for an unusually long term.
• Exclusivity: Most contracts are exclusive, meaning you agree to work only with this agent for the life of the agreement. This is standard industry practice.
• Cancellation Policy (Termination Clause): What’s the escape hatch if things go south? A fair agreement will have a straightforward clause explaining how you or the agent can end the relationship if it's not working out.

Trust Your Gut Feeling

All the data, interviews, and reference checks give you a logical basis for making a smart decision. They're absolutely critical. But when all the analysis is done, you have to listen to your intuition.

This is a person you'll be in constant contact with, entrusting them with what is likely one of the biggest financial moves you'll ever make. Do you actually like them? Do you feel a real connection? More importantly, do you trust them to have your back when things get messy? That feeling of rapport is often what separates a good agent from the right agent.

With the agreement signed, your agent officially joins your team. They are now your point person for navigating the complex, and sometimes confusing, world of buying property abroad. To get a head start on what's coming, take a look at our guide on the https://residaro.com/blog/real-estate-due-diligence-checklist. It will walk you through the detailed work your new partner will soon be helping you tackle.

A Few Common Questions We Hear All the Time

When you're figuring out how to choose a real estate agent, a few key questions always seem to pop up. They’re important, and getting solid answers can be the difference between a nightmare process and a smooth, confident home-buying journey. Let's dig into some of the things buyers, especially from overseas, often ask.

Can I Just Work With a Bunch of Agents at Once?

It’s tempting to think that having more agents on your side means you’ll see more properties, but this approach almost always backfires. Here's why: most real estate agents work on 100% commission. They pour hours, days, and sometimes weeks into a client's search, and they only get paid when you actually close on a house with them.

When an agent knows you’re committed, they’re motivated to put you at the top of their list. They'll dig deep, call their contacts, and really advocate for you. But if they know you're just one of several agents you're talking to? They're far less likely to invest that same level of energy. It's much smarter to do your homework, find one fantastic agent, and build a loyal, trusting relationship.

Think of it this way: You wouldn't hire three different personal trainers for the same fitness goal and expect any of them to give you their best work. You pick one expert and you commit. It’s the same principle.

What’s This Going to Cost Me? How Much is a Buyer's Agent?

This is a big one, and thankfully, the answer is usually a pleasant surprise. For the most part, as a buyer, you don't directly pay your agent. Their commission is typically paid by the seller out of the sale proceeds.

In a standard U.S. transaction, the seller pays a total commission—often around 5-6% of the home's sale price. That amount is then split between their own agent and your agent. This system is designed so that every buyer can have professional representation without a huge upfront cost. Just make sure you confirm this standard practice in your buyer representation agreement before you sign anything.

What If My Agent and I Just Aren't Clicking?

It happens. Even after all your research and interviews, you might find the working relationship isn't what you'd hoped for. This is exactly what the buyer representation agreement is for. Any professional contract worth its salt will have a termination clause spelling out the rules for parting ways.

Before you pull the plug, though, try having a frank conversation. Tell your agent what's not working for you. Is it a lack of communication? Are your expectations not being met? Often, a simple, honest chat can clear the air and get things back on track.

If that doesn't work, go back to your contract. You might have to give a certain amount of notice, but you should never feel stuck in a bad situation. A truly good agent wants their clients to be happy, even if that means admitting it's not a good fit and letting you move on.

Is the Commission Rate Set in Stone, or Can I Negotiate?

Technically, commissions can be negotiated, but it's a tricky area you should approach with caution. An agent’s commission isn’t just a random fee; it covers their expertise, their time, and a whole host of services, from deep market analysis to navigating mountains of paperwork and keeping the deal alive through inspections and appraisals.

Trying to haggle with a top-performing agent for a lower rate can send the wrong signal. An agent who easily agrees to cut their commission might be one who also cuts corners on service to make up the difference. Instead of fixating on the percentage, focus on the value. A brilliant agent who negotiates a better price on your home or saves a deal from falling apart is worth infinitely more than the fraction of a percent you might have saved on their fee.

---

At Residaro, we connect you with exceptional properties across Europe, making your dream of owning a home abroad a reality. Start your journey today by exploring our exclusive listings. Find your perfect European property on residaro.com.